A Messsage from the Section Chair

Welcome to the Philadelphia Bar Association's Criminal Justice Section Website. Part of the purpose of the Criminal Justice Section is to further the achievement of fair, speedy, and effective administration of criminal justice. In promoting that purpose, our Section has s long-standing tradition of carefully examining issues that impact the practice of law in Philadelphia and the criminal-justice system. Because our membership is comprised of a wide range of stakeholders in the criminal-justice system, including judges, prosecutors, public defenders and private practitioners, we are able to speak to criminal-justice issues from a broad and robust perspective.

Some of our recent work and initiatives include the Free Student Research Center for members who are court appointed to represent indigent defendants (state and federal), ensuring the retention of experienced and competent court-appointed counsel in the Philadelphia court system, providing eduction and relevant information to our members through the Criminal Justice Section Blog, and providing high-quality continuing-legal education (CLE) Programs with the Pennsylvania Bar Institute.

You are invited to attend our monthly section meetings. They are held on the last Tuesday of each month at the Philadelphia Bar Association, 1101 Market St. At our meetings, you will experience our appellate update, prison updates, topical guest speakers from the criminal-justice community and opportunities to earn CLE credits.

Please join us at our meetings. Lunch is provided at a small cost. We look forward to seeing you.

Chair

Brad V. Shuttleworth, Esq.
Alva & Associates
1601 Market Street
Suite 1001
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Telephone: (215) 665.1695

MONTHLY SECTION MEETINGS

  • January 25, 2011
  • February 22, 2011
  • March 29, 2011
  • April 26, 2011
  • My 31, 2011
  • June 28, 2011
  • July 26, 2011
  • August 30, 2011
  • September 27, 2011
  • October 25, 2011
  • November 29, 2011
  • December 27, 2011

  • Section News

    The Criminal Justice Section Student Research Center will re-open on June 13, 2011. The hours of operation will be Monday through Thursday from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. The SRC, located in Room 303 of the Criminal Justice Center (The Jack Meyer's lawyer’s lounge), offers free case law research for court appointed and CJA counsel. The research is provided by law students from local area law schools. Attorneys wishing to request research assistance on an appointed case can do so either by visiting the lawyer’s lounge directly and meeting with a law student in person or they may submit a research request online via the Student Research Center tab on the left side of the Criminal Justice Section website.

    The Criminal Justice Section will make every effort to house multiple students in the lawyer’s lounge during its operating hours. However, given the multiple commitments that law students manage, it is possible that the student research center will not be fully staffed at all times. Therefore, whether you submit a request online or in person you should first contact the lounge at 3-7538 or 3-7539 (CJC internal only) or phillysrc1@gmail.com to check student availability.

    A special word of gratitude must go out to the Hon. Lillian Harris Ransom, the Honorable Rayford A. Means and our Student Research Center Co-Chairs, Gabriel Hindin, Esq., and Ellen Cantillon, Esq.


    Please keep checking the Criminal Justice Section area of the Philadelphia Bar Association website and the Criminal Justice Section Blog for important news and updates.

    New Judicial Courtroom Assignments

    Judicial Assignments for November 1, 2010 through July 1, 2011


    The Criminal Justice Section offers prosecutors, defense attorneys and judges the opportunity to meet and collaborate on issues of mutual concern within the criminal justice system. Membership in the section is available not only to lawyers and judges; any person employed within the criminal justice system in Philadelphia, or by the courts, is eligible to become an associate member of the section. In addition to continuing legal education courses developed specifically for criminal law practitioners, the section also sponsors public forums on issues of concern to the broader community.

    The Criminal Justice Section has three awards:

    1. Thurgood Marshall Award (formerly the Criminal Justice Section Award). It is presented at our annual holiday party in December.

    2. Cesare Beccaria Award. It is presented every November at a reception in the Mayor's Reception Room in City Hall. The Justinian Society participates in the award and presentation.

    3. Henry Czajkowski Award. This award was created in 1996 to honor the late Hank Czajkowski, an outstanding court administrator. It is to be presented from time to time to non-lawyers who have made outstanding contributions to the administration of justice. In 1996 it was presented to Joseph A. Cairone.

    STANDARDS FOR AWARDING THE THURGOOD MARSHALL AWARD

    The purpose of the Award is to represent the highest honor that the Criminal Justice Section can give to anyone, whether or not a member of the Section, who exemplifies the ideals of Justice Thurgood Marshall's career. The Award should be for long-time service, not an individual event, although a specific event can be the triggering factor.

    1. It should be awarded to someone who has devoted time, energy and talent to improving the standards of justice in the Philadelphia and Pennsylvania courts.

    2. It should recognize significant accomplishments in improving the administration of criminal justice.

    3. It should recognize signficant accomplishments in achieving the goals of the Criminal Justice Section.

    4. It should recognize distinguished service consistently rendered over a considerable period of time or a single outstanding achievement in a particular year. (The fact that this single achievement may have occured some years ago is not material so long as it has not been recognized).

    5. It should not be awarded merely for exemplary permance in a paid job relating to criminal justice. It should represent service above and beyond compensated employment.

    6. The recipient should demonstrate great legal talent, administrative abilities or devotion to a cause, whether popular or not. For example, a lawyer (prosecutor or defense) who represents unpopular causes or unpopular defendants; a judge who develops innovative techniques for disposing of cases without minimizing rights of defendants or victims; an administrator who devises new systems of disposing cases; an organization which makes an innovative contribution to the criminal justice system; an individual or organization which fosters legal education and training.

    Thurgood Marshall Award Recipients:

    • Co-Recipients, Maureen Rowley, Esq. and Michael Coard, Esq.
    • Judge Darnell C. Jones II
    • George Henry Newman, Esq.
    • A. Charles Peruto, Esq.
    • Judge Stanley Kubacki
    • Stanford Shmukler, Esq.
    • Judge Lois Forer
    • Bruce A. Franzel, Esq.
    • Burton A. Rose, Esq.
    • Judge Carolyn Engel Temin
    • Steven G. Laver, Esq.
    • Judge Legrome Davis
    • Councilman David Cohen
    • Deputy District Attorney Raymond Harley
    • Judge Anthony J. DeFino
    • Judith Frankel Rubino, Esq.
    • Hon. Abram Frank Reynolds
    • Bernard L. Siegel, Esq.
    • Judge Benjamin Lerner.
    • George Henry Newman, Esq.
    • Co-Recipients, Maureen Rowley, Esq. and Michael Coard, Esq.
    • Co-Recipients, George Mosee, Esq. and Hon. Louis H. Pollak
    • Ellen T. Greenlee, Esq.

    STANDARDS FOR AWARDING THE BECCARIA AWARD

    This Award represents the highest honor that the Criminal Justice Section can give to any member of the Bar, whether or not a member of the Section, who exemplifies the ideals of the career of Cesare Beccaria, the 18th century Italian scholar whose writings presaged the dawn of the modern penal system. The Award is to recognize distinguished achievement of a member of the Philadelphia Bar in the field of education in criminal justice, including legal and/or general education activities in the field.

    Beccaria published a book in 1764 advocating a new and complete system of criminal law and procedure stressing swift trials, prompt, moderate and certain punishment, rehabilitation and the abolition of the death penalty. However, advocacy of these principles should not be the only criteria for the Award.

    1. It should be awarded to someone who has devoted time, energy and talent to educating and improving the standards of education in the Philadelphia and Pennsylvania area in the field of criminal justice.

    2. It should recognize significant accomplishments in improving educational principles in the criminal field.

    3. It should recognize significant accomplishments in achieving the goals of the Criminal Justice Section.

    4. It should recognize distinguished service consistently rendered over a considerable period of time or a single outstanding achievement in a particular year. (The fact that this single achievement may have occurred some years ago is not material so long as it has not been previously recognized).

    5. It should not be awarded merely for exemplary performance in a paid job relating to criminal education, but should represent service above and beyond compensated employment.

    6. The recipient should demonstrate legal educational efforts, development of new and innovative courses in criminal education, and should foster legal education and training in the field of criminal justice.

    Beccaria Award Recipients

    • University of Pennsylvania Law Professor David Rudovsky
    • Michael C. Rainone

    CRIMINAL JUSTICE SECTION CHAIRS

    1966 Brem Levy, Esquire
    1967 Brem Levy, Esquire
    1968 Stanford Shmukler, Esquire
    1969 Stanford Shmukler, Esquire
    1970 Sarah Duffy, Esquire
    1974 Donald J. Goldberg, Esquire
    1975 Howard Gittis, Esquire
    1976 Dennis Eisman, Esquire
    1977 Richard D. Atkins, Esquire
    1978 William D. Harris, Esquire
    1979 Eugene H. Clarke, Jr., Esquire
    1980 Louis M. Natale, Esquire
    1981 Joel H. Slomsky, Esquire
    1982 Michael D. Stiles, Esquire
    1983 Bruce A. Franzel, Esquire
    1984 Burton A. Rose, Esquire
    1985 Leon W. Tucker, Esquire
    1986 Jane C. Greenspan, Esquire
    1987 George H. Newman, Esquire
    1988 Stanton M. Lacks, Esquire
    1989 Andrew Gay, Esquire
    1990 Bernard L. Siegel, Esquire
    1991 Steven A. Morley, Esquire
    1992 Steven G. Laver, Esquire
    1993 Teresa Carr Deni, Esquire
    1994 Samuel C. Stretton, Esquire
    1995 Denis Cohen, Esquire
    1996 Aaron Finestone, Esquire
    1997 Ellen Greenlee, Esquire
    1998 Daniel-Paul Alva, Esquire
    1999 Jack Myers, Esquire
    2000 Isla Fruchter, Esquire
    2001 Stanley Krakower, Esquire
    2002 Daniel P. Alva, Esquire
    2003 Matthew Perks, Esquire
    2004 George H. Newman, Esquire
    2005 Judith Frankel Rubino, Esquire
    2006 John Ryan, Esquire
    2007 Donna Woelpper, Esquire
    2008 Troy W. Wilson, Esq.
    2009 Peter Berson, Esq.
    2010 Hon. Denis P. Cohen and Thomas O. Fitzpatrick, Esq. (co-Chairs)
    Note: Names not available for 1971, 1972, 1973


    CRIMINAL JUSTICE SECTION AWARD RECIPIENTS

    1976 Brem Levy, Esquire
    1977 Martin Vinikoor, Esquire
    1982 Louis Lipschitz, Esquire, Abe Needleman, Esquire, Herbert Hardin, Esquire, Brem Levy, Esquire, Milton Leidner, Esquire
    1988 Edward Dennis, Esquire
    1989 Samuel C. Stretton, Esquire
    Note: (year uncertain) Senator Arlen Specter, Stanford Shmukler, Esquire

    Note: Names not available for 1978, 1979, 1980, 1981, 1983, 1984, l985, 1986, 1987

    THURGOOD MARSHALL AWARD RECIPIENTS

    1991 A. Charles Peruto, Esquire, Judge Stanley Kubacki
    1992 Stanford Shmukler, Esquire
    1993 Judge Lois Forer
    1994 Bruce A. Franzel, Esquire
    1995 Burton A. Rose, Esquire
    1996 Judge Carolyn Engel Temin
    1997 Steven G. Laver, Esquire
    1998 Judge Legrome Davis
    1999 Councilperson David Cohen
    2000 Deputy District Attorney Raymond Harley
    2001 Judge Anthony J. DeFino
    2002 Judith Frankel Rubino, Esquire
    2003 Hon. Abram Frank Reynolds
    2004 Bernard L. Siegel, Esquire
    2005 Judge Benjamin Lerner
    2006 George Henry Newman, Esquire
    2008 Co-Recipients, Maureen Rowley, Esq. and Michael Coard, Esq.
    2009 Co-Recipients, George Mosee, Esq. and Hon. Louis H. Pollak
    2010 Ellen T. Greenlee, Esq.

    BECCARIA AWARD RECIPIENTS

    1994 Judge Lisa Richette
    1995 Professor James Strazzella
    1996 Judge Abraham Gafni
    1997 Mary DeFusco, Esquire
    1998 Professor Edward Ohlbaum, Judge Louis Presenza
    1999 Judge Edmund B. Spaeth, Jr., Donald Marino, Esquire
    2000 L. Felipe Restrepo, Esquire
    2001 Judge Anthony J. Scirica
    2002 Judge Charles P. Mirarchi, Jr.
    2003 Jules Epstein, Esquire
    2004 A. Charles Peruto Sr.
    2005 David Rudovsky, Esquire
    2006 Michael Rainone, Equire
    2007 Hon. Carolyn Engel Temin
    2008 Hon. Anthony J. DeFino
    2009 Gaetan J. Alfano, Esq.
    2010 Frank DeSimone, Esq.

    HENRY CZAJKOWSKI AWARD RECIPIENTS

    (Presented for Administration of Justice -- not for lawyers or judges)
    1996 Joseph A. Cairone
    2001 Kathleen Rapone
    2005 Stephen Jaffe
    2008 Philadelphia Police Department Detective Bill Wynn (Ret.)
    2010 Joseph A. Lanzalotti, Deputy Court Administrator for the First Judicial District of Pennsylvania